
PART1
Tennessee carried out the death penalty this morning, executing serial rapist and murderer Harold Nichols. >> Nichols was sentenced to death after confessing to the 1988 rape and murder of 20-year-old Karen Polley in Chattanooga. She was asleep. He was already inside. And he was holding a board.
When investigators finally asked him one question, would he have stopped on his own? He didn’t hesitate. He said no. This is not a story pulled from a crime novel. This is not a fictional thriller. What you are about to hear is a real case, a real woman, a real crime, and a legal battle that took 37 years to reach its conclusion.
Karen Elise Polley was 20 years old. She was not a headline. She was not a case number. She was a young woman with a plan for her life and every reason to believe it was just getting started. Karen was a student at Chattanooga State Community College working toward a career as a paralegal. Before college, she had walked the halls of Brainerd Baptist High School, the same Brainerd community where she later made her home as a cheerleader.