Then he underwent his own religious conversion. By 1998, he was one of Tucker’s most vocal public opponents of her sentence being carried out. The other side was equally clear. Richard Thornton, Deborah’s husband, never wavered. He did not believe the transformation was genuine and stated consistently that it was irrelevant to the legal outcome.
Diane Clemens, president of the Houston victim’s rights group Justice for All, called the campaign to spare Tucker a combination of fraud, gender bias, and misplaced sentimentality. Texas Attorney General Dan Morales stood by the state’s position. The ACLU opposed the execution, but on broad anti-death penalty grounds, not because of anything specific to Tucker’s case.
On January 28th, 1998, the Texas Board of Pardons and Parles voted 16 to0 against clemency. Two members abstained. Governor Bush was asked two questions when evaluating her request. Was there any doubt about her guilt? And had she received the full protection of the law? The answers were no and yes. He declined to intervene.
Outside the Huntsville unit on the night of February 3rd, 1998, an estimated 200 reporters from around the world had gathered. Protesters held candles. A gospel singer began performing Amazing Grace. The pro-execution crowd outside the prison gates shouted it down. On February 2nd, Tucker had been transported by state aircraft from the Mountain View unit in Gatesville, 160 mi, to the Huntsville unit.
That evening, Alan Palinsky, chairman of the Texas Board of Criminal Justice, came to her cell. Someone offered him a chair. He refused it. He sat on the concrete floor because he did not want to look down at her. Tucker handed him a three-page document, not a personal plea, but a structured proposal for prison reform covering inmate labor programs, postrelease accountability, and support systems for women still inside.
Her husband, Dana Brown, visited through a screen. They could not make physical contact. In their final moments together, they shook hands through the glass. Tucker was brought to tears. It was the last time they would ever touch. Between 8:00 a.m. and noon on February 3rd, Tucker visited with her father, Larry Tucker, and her sister, Carrie Weeks. That goodbye lasted four hours.
At 100 p.m., she was moved to the holding cell adjacent to the execution chamber, transported the short distance in an armored van per Huntsville protocol. Her requested final meal was a banana, a peach, and a garden salad with ranch dressing. She declined a sedative. She wanted to be fully present.
At 3:30 p.m., women’s chaplain, Cheryl Archer, arrived and sat with her on the floor, holding hands through the bars. Tucker’s attorney, David Botszford, had sent a note. Cheryl read it aloud. The fifth circuit court had denied the final appeal. At 2:45 p.m., Al Gonzalez had called from Governor Bush’s office and would call again. Tucker looked down.
Then she looked up and told Cheryl, “I am at peace with this. Tell the women to forgive.” At 6:12 p.m., Bush’s office formally confirmed the execution would proceed. Captain Fred Allen escorted Tucker the 20 ft from the holding cell into the execution chamber. Her four chosen witnesses were Carrie Weeks, Dana Brown, Jackie Anen, and Ronald Carlson.
In the separate observation room for the victim’s families, Richard Thornton sat in a wheelchair alongside Deborah’s son, William Joseph Davis, and step-daughter, Catherine Thornton. No one was present to represent Jerry Lind Dean. His family had not been contacted in time. Tucker addressed the Thornton family and Jerry Dean’s family directly said she was sorry and told them she hoped God would give them peace.