Skip to content 
Yeah. Oh, Jim Bob blank. Jim Bob. Do you have gloves? Need some more. Oh my. These cats were not dead when she put them in there. There’s a mama in there box with her group of her dead baby kittens. 22? Yeah, make sure. Make sure. Nothing else in there? Even if the box has hamburgers on it, make sure it’s hamburgers.
Yeah, cuz they used that as all of the food. That’s just insane. Inside the freezer, officers discover 24 dead cats and kittens stuffed into cardboard boxes alongside frozen food. Even more unsettling is the fact that the way their bodies are curled up raises the possibility that they may have been frozen alive.
The scene is deeply disturbing and even seasoned officers are shaken by what they’re seeing. As they begin sorting through the discovery, >> [music] >> the woman who made the welfare call, the child’s older sister, arrives at the scene to take custody of the 10-year-old. She also explains the situation leading up to her welfare call, the final piece of the puzzle officers require.
Um we’ve actually I’ve already had her at our residence. Um she was temporarily with me for a little while. It’s probably going to be a lot longer. Um It’s going to be up to It’s going to be up to her ultimately. We don’t deal in that. We won’t even come to your house. We can’t go to baby. Yeah. But if it’s like this, then it won’t happen. Oh, I know.
So if it’s It’s It’s fine. Okay. Um so it’s This has been an ongoing issue for a while, but my birthday is this Monday and she was supposed to We’re going to Cherokee for the weekend. And she was supposed to come with us. And my mom doesn’t celebrate holidays. Um so she had said that she had made last-minute plans for the four couldn’t come with us.
Um and just told me that she’d moved some people into the home that had just gotten out of jail, so I didn’t feel comfortable leaving her here with random people. Okay. Because other than Body, I’m not sure who else is here. Well, Body’s probably not a good person to be around. >> Oh, no, he’s not. I’ve had a few issues with Body.
Me and Body have just gotten called out here because we fist fought. Um about a year ago, I beat him with a PVC pipe. Her explanation confirms once and for all that Samantha should never have had custody of the child to begin with. Both Samantha Plotts and Body Williams are charged with 24 counts of aggravated animal cruelty as the full scale of the case comes to light.
Samantha also faces an additional charge of second-degree endangering the welfare of a minor. In December 2025, Body Williams accepts a plea deal for one count of aggravated cruelty to a dog or cat, receiving 36 months of probation along with a ban on owning or being around pets. Meanwhile, Samantha continues to wait for her trial as the legal battle surrounding this case is far from over.